Cartoon-style image of “Stick to the Plan Stan,” a determined trader checking off trades on a 20-trade BoS strategy sheet while chaos erupts around him

Trade 12 of 20 – Edge Over Emotion

We’re now on Trade 12 of 20 in our commitment to execute the 1-Minute BoS Sniper Strategy with discipline.

And today? Today was a test.

After yesterday’s lesson on trusting higher timeframe bias, I came in focused on doing things right. So when the setup showed up the first time—1-minute BoS, volume, clear structure—I didn’t take it. My higher timeframe bias was bearish, so I passed.

And of course… that trade would have worked.

Price tagged liquidity to the penny and ripped straight to TP2. Here’s what that looked like:

Skipped 1-minute BoS long trade on NQ that tagged liquidity and ran to TP2 after high-volume move
Trade 12 of 20: This was the long setup we skipped due to bearish higher timeframe bias. Tagged liquidity to the tick with high volume and ran 166.5 points—easily a TP2 winner.

So when the setup appeared again—this time with a small spike in volume near the 10 SMA and a retrace into a 15-minute FVG—I took it. I was stopped out almost immediately.

1-minute BoS short trade entry into 15-minute FVG with volume just over 10 SMA, stopped out immediately
Trade 12 of 20: Took a short entry after 1-minute BoS into a 15-minute fair value gap with volume slightly above the 10 SMA. Stopped out instantly.

Was the setup valid? Yes. But I wasn’t in the best mindset. I felt like I had fumbled the first one. And I “knew” this setup would come again. Classic trap. Plus, I got a terrible fill on Topstep (not a complaint, just a fact), so I was down $225 fast.

At that point, I broke a rule.
I took the same setup again.

It wasn’t revenge trading in the explosive, emotional sense—but it definitely wasn’t detached execution. I saw the same pattern play out: high volume spike into the 15-minute FVG, a fresh BoS—and I took it. This time, I managed it better. Took some early profit to reduce risk, and ended the day down just $48 instead of taking the full hit again.

Second 1-minute BoS short entry into 15-minute FVG that reduced the day’s loss but would have stopped out if held
Trade 12 of 20: This was the second short entry—taken after a second 1-minute BoS into the same 15-minute FVG. It helped recover part of the earlier loss, but would have stopped out had it been held.

Let me be clear: you don’t see me getting mad and blowing up the account.
You don’t see me revenge trading with oversized positions. I took the same setup, with the same risk, even though I shouldn’t have taken another trade at all.

That doesn’t make it okay. But it does show growth.

And that’s what you need to be asking yourself:
Are you staying in control?
Are you managing your risk?
Are you taking the same setup each time so you can actually learn from your results?

If the answer is no, then you’re not trading—you’re reacting.

Topstep trade log showing two entries, one stop out, one partial, and final close with $48 loss on the day
Trade 12 of 20: Topstep confirmation of both trades taken—first stopped out, second managed with partial profit. Final result: -$48 and more data for the edge.

This hasn’t exactly been a hot streak. We’ve had a lot of losses with this strategy so far. And while every day, every week, and every month won’t be profitable—that’s just part of trading—it still stings.

But that’s why we’re doing this.

If we jump ship after a handful of losses, we never give the edge a chance to reveal itself. And more importantly, we never find out what actually needs to be fixed. Real progress only happens after enough data is collected. That’s the purpose behind the 20-trade commitment.

Today is just another day of data. That’s all.

Every trade—win or lose—is a datapoint. We’ll analyze the full sample when we hit 20. Then we’ll evaluate. Then we’ll adjust. Not now.

What We’ll Learn After 20 Trades

  • Is the edge truly profitable as designed?
  • Are we more successful with or without volume confirmation?
  • Does trading with higher timeframe bias matter?
  • Are our entries too early? Should we wait for deeper pullbacks?
  • How much does TopStep slippage impact real results?
  • Are we better off taking full TP1s, or is holding for TP2 hurting us?

These are not decisions we’ll make emotionally. These are changes we’ll only consider after the full 20-trade set is complete.

NASDAQ chart showing perfect reaction to marked high-probability level and confirmation of BoS setup
The NASDAQ tagged our marked high-probability level to the penny and reversed. Proof that these areas work—and why we track them every day.

This is why we log every trade and track our reactions. So that by trade 20, we’ll have clarity.

Whether you’re using this strategy or your own, you should be doing the same thing: taking the same setup, day after day, and documenting the outcomes. That’s the only way to refine your edge. And if you take more than one trade per day—as I did today—make sure it’s the same setup. That way, your data is still useful.

Profit comes from staying in the game and sticking to a system long enough to let the probabilities work.
That’s how we win—not by guessing the future.

Cartoon-style image of “Stick to the Plan Stan,” a determined trader checking off trades on a 20-trade BoS strategy sheet while chaos erupts around him
Categories